Cathardincu Surprisingly incoherent and boring

Lumsdal Good , But It Is Overrated By Some

StyleSk8r At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.

Sabah Hensley This is a dark and sometimes deeply uncomfortable drama

misctidsandbits This film came out in the author, Catherine Marshall's lifetime, and we have her comments on it. She was overall very pleased. She considered that 20th Century Fox gave it a quality and credible handling. She thought Richard Todd did a fine job. She was, however, politely puzzled by the interpretation of herself by the actress, Jean Peters. Apparently, this was not a particularly welcome project for Ms. Peters, who gave no response to the usual functions and support of an actor for their picture, not attending the premier or anything of that nature. She resisted any friendly overtures from Mrs. Marshall while visiting the set during the filming, as the invited guest of the studio. All of this was opposite to the response of Mr. Todd, who was very gracious. Mrs. Marshall knew she had signed away her rights to affect the production, and did not attempt to interfere. Ms. Peters' portrayal was adequate as the young girl in love, but she was quite artificial in the marriage and ministry period. The boy who played the son was more alive and natural. She depicted Mrs. Marshall as either a simpering hanger-on or as sort of a weary worn, martyr type, who doggedly trudged through. If she read the book itself, she certainly missed the spark and proactive quality of the woman she was playing. Having read the book, along with others of Mrs. Marshall, I know that she was most enthusiastic and positive toward her life with Rev. Marshall and life in general. And, she was an active contributor. Her inner strength also won out as she faced her many personal challenges. If you have the interest, you might enjoy reading Catherine Marshall's book by the same name. As for the film, TCM ran it as part of a feature of Richard Todd, and FMC used to run it rather regularly.

Barbara Alley As a biographical film, the viewer is called upon to consider their faith, their relationship with Jesus, and whom they choose to worship. Peter Marshall denied his will to be a captain at Sea to follow the will of God. Within 10 years of following His lead, God groomed Peter to play a significant and important role in a prim New York society and eventually in the Senate. Hollywood produced this film with full sermons which were needed in 1955, a time when Hollywood was under investigation for communism. The message contained in this rare film remains relevant as our current Senate and the intentions of our countries leaders are called into question. Praise God for His wisdom by enabling the voice of Peter Marshall to live on.

marjorie_wilson This movie made in 1955 I recorded off the AMC station last week. finally started watching it. It is a wonderful movie. Peter Marshall was portrayed so well as a completely devoted Man of God. And his choice of a bride and mate for life was as much of a blessing as any other thing portrayed in this movie. It is delightful to see something that does not offend the senses. Dodd was able to play this man in such a manner that you thought they were one and the same person. The same was true of the woman who fell in love with him so quickly. I have emailed several of my friends to encourage them to seek this in DVD form to watch. It is well worth the time it takes. It is delightfully produced and directed. For some people it could be too slow by today's standards, but for me it was an encouraging and uplifting story of a man who was well-know and loved in our country's history.

Rick-Swain It is a long time since I have seen an 'old' film that has seemed so relevant to the problems facing western society. I think that Richard Todd is excellent in the role of Peter Marshall. He captures the dynamism and belief of Marshall. His sermons from the pulpit are full of power and conviction and they have made me want to read more of his sermons and prayers. I would also be interested to find out more about how he was viewed by his contemporaries. I found the address on December 7th particularly moving and I would recommend this film as one that will not disappoint. I am amazed that being in my 50's I had never heard of this film before.