NekoHomey Purely Joyful Movie!

Bea Swanson This film is so real. It treats its characters with so much care and sensitivity.

Mehdi Hoffman There's a more than satisfactory amount of boom-boom in the movie's trim running time.

Staci Frederick Blistering performances.

atlasmb In this Andy Hardy installment, Andy is less girl crazy than in others. That is probably due to a shift in focus to Kathryn Grayson, making her noteworthy debut as Andy's classmate. It is understandable that MGM would want their newest surefire star to make a big splash in a vehicle that would guarantee plenty of viewers.Judge Hardy teaches Andy lessons in charity and citizenship while assisting a family fallen on difficult times. Andy's classmates-Kathryn and Harry Land-are given roles in the high school graduation festivities as part of this project. Naturally, we get to hear Kathryn's amazing singing voice.Andy, who is wrapped up in every aspect of the ceremonies, spreads himself too thin, but Kathryn becomes his private secretary, helping him with his organization. Still, he manages to bungle important details, causing consternation and some major problems.Miss Grayson holds her own, acting-wise, with the rest of the cast, and her singing voice is a singular joy that surely must have wowed audiences in 1941. Still, she lacks the effervescence of another singing starlet who graces Andy Hardy films-Judy Garland, who would match Mickey Rooney's energy and hep-cred in various film pairings.

MartinHafer In this 10th installment of the Andy Hardy series, Andy is class president and he's spending a lot of time with the class secretary, Kathryn (Kathryn Grayson). Naturally, Polly (Ann Rutherford) is jealous, but that's the least of the problems--it seems that Kathryn and her brother are going to be leaving the country just days before their graduation! So, Andy tries to fix things....and totally mucks it up! Additionally, he and the gang work on a school play, his car falls apart while Judge Hardy is driving it and Andy MIGHT not be graduating after all. As far as graduating goes, it IS about time as Mickey Rooney was 21 when he made this film*! If he doesn't graduate soon, he'll soon be collecting social security while still a student! None of it is really the least bit earth-shaking--just the usual family stuff you'll see in an Andy Hardy film. It's generally pleasant and entertaining with one exception. While Kathryn Grayson was lovely and enjoyable in the film, the studio's insistence of having her sing an operatic piece 46 minutes into the film was just dreadful--the same with the song at the 87 minute mark. Some in the audience might have liked it but I suspect most used that time to either take a brief nap or get some popcorn!*The not graduating angle never made a lot of sense. Andy's supposed to be one of the top kids in his class yet did badly on his final English exam and failed. Odd--especially since Andy thought he was going to get an award for scholarship! Can Andy be this insane?! It just didn't seem realistic.

wes-connors About to graduate from Carvel High School, hopefully college-bound Andy (Mickey Rooney) becomes interested in helping a poor family. He even bounces a $280 check for the impoverished Lands, which is covered by Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone). Both judge and son try to help the family. They are under-employed service station mechanic Ian Hunter (as Steven Land), opera-singing daughter Kathryn Grayson (as Kathryn) and piano-playing son Todd Karns (as Harry). Andy goes as far as hiring Ms. Grayson as his "Private Secretary," which angers girlfriend Ann Rutherford (as Polly Benedict). Due to Andy's overly helpful machinations, he may not graduate...MGM often featured potential new stars in "Andy Hardy" films, herein they are Kathryn Grayson and Todd Karns. Obviously spotlighted, Ms. Grayson became a successful musical star. Her main style of singing is "sophisticated" opera, however, which may pierce some ears. This is acknowledged in the script, by a teen-aged "Andy" more interested in listening to the era's pop music. You don't jitterbug to Kathryn Grayson. "Private Secretary" is the first film in the series without big sister Cecilia Parker (as Marian), although she would still be pictured in the series introduction. While it became clearly "Andy Hardy", the series official title remained "Judge Hardy's Family".**** Andy Hardy's Private Secretary (2/21/41) George B. Seitz ~ Mickey Rooney, Kathryn Grayson, Lewis Stone, Todd Karns

toolkien Most of the Hardy movies has a bit of the conservatives call "bleeding heart" element to them. It isn't ever too preachy, and it isn't here either, but it does tend to stretch a bit of the credulity when the people on the "wrong side of the tracks" are a gorgeous opera singer, a handsome, intelligent Harry Bailey of It's a Wonderful Life in another role, and an erudite, handsome father needing a second chance. Not exactly Dead End Kids material. It was toward the end of the depression where everyone down on their luck it wasn't their fault. But there are limits of suspension of disbelief.The rest of the installment is standard fare - the girl trouble, the car trouble, the light drama (of the later installments anyway), a bit of choppiness in the unfolding of the story lines - a pleasant way to spend an hour and a half.