IslandGuru Who payed the critics

Marketic It's no definitive masterpiece but it's damn close.

Tacticalin An absolute waste of money

Sharkflei Your blood may run cold, but you now find yourself pinioned to the story.

Sara Martin Spectators' opinions may differ very much but when films get reviewed by very few persons, they are bound to be unfairly judged. This is the case of 'Barcelona, nit d'hivern' which partly follows from the delicious 'Barcelona nit d'estiu', and which is also a delicious comedy. There is absolutely nothing trite or predictable in this film, which reflects very well Barcelona's local colour in its situations and characters. The formula used to bring diverse characters together may be nothing new but what these characters feel and the solutions they find to their quandaries is often original - at least it is hard to recall a scene like the family dinner and the announcement which the grandmother makes. Give yourself a treat, and enjoy 'Barcelona nit d'hivern'...

moondog-8 I don't think very highly of the creative team for this movie because the only way they know to communicate how a person feels or reacts is to have a big closeup of the actor's head while he or she talks (and talks and talks and talks) about how he feels and what he or she feels about the other people. It's rather insulting when a creative person doesn't trust the audience's ability to understand something, and so everything is spelled out like this movie does. Gestures, facial expressions, mood lighting, colors, objects within a scene -- all these ways of communicating with an audience and making the audience curious are seriously under-used. 75% of the dialogue could have been left out; and if the camera had moved in or out more to show detail or give us the bigger picture, it would have been a much richer movie. As it is, it's a series of people's heads with their lips moving ... and saying things that are pretty trite and predictable.