Diagonaldi Very well executed

AboveDeepBuggy Some things I liked some I did not.

Stoutor It's not great by any means, but it's a pretty good movie that didn't leave me filled with regret for investing time in it.

CrawlerChunky In truth, there is barely enough story here to make a film.

JohnHowardReid Eric Portman (Eddie Tribe/Mendover), Ann Todd (Frankie), Maxwell Reed (Olaf Tyson), Edward Rigby (Bill Shackle), Bill Owen (Ron), Jane Hylton (Doris, the barmaid), Garry Marsh (customer), Eliot Makeham (Bigley, the solicitor), Margaret Withers (Mrs Bigley), John Turnbull (police superintendent), Maurice Denham (police inspector), Lyn Evans (waterman), Milton Rosmer (prison governor).Director: COMPTON BENNETT. Screenplay: Muriel Box, Sydney Box. Story: Monckton Hoffe. Photography: Reginald H. Wyer. Film editors: Helga Cranston, Peter Price. Music: Benjamin Frankel, conducted by Muir Mathieson. Art director: James Carter. Costumes: Dorothy Sinclair. Make-up: Nell Taylor. Camera operator: Bernard Lewis. Assistant director: Basil Keys. Sound recording: John Mitchell, Stephen Dalby. Associate producer: A. Frank Bundy. Producer: Sydney Box.Not copyrighted in the U.S.A. Released through Universal- International in the U.S.A.: July 1949. New York opening at the Little Carnegie: 2 July 1949. U.K. release through General Film Distributors: 5 July 1948. Australian release through Fox: 7 July 1950 (sic). 7,389 feet. 82 minutes.SYNOPSIS: Eddie Tribe, a middle-aged, somewhat aloof but wealthy barge-owner, marries a young piece of flotsam without telling her of his two side jobs where he works under his Mendover alias: (1) barber; (2) public hangman.COMMENT: "Daybreak" is what the trade used to categorize as a difficult film. Its theme and unrelievedly downbeat atmosphere far too grim for both the cloth cap and carriage trade, the movie's only hope of success lay with the critics. Enthusiastic reviews have solved many a problem picture. But not so with this one. My review was probably the best of the lot, although Photoplayer was never the prestigious sort of magazine that could be quoted in advertising. Here it is: "Director Compton Bennett and scriptwriters Muriel and Sydney Box create quite an interesting and suspenseful atmosphere in this unusual melodrama — though they rather spoil it by showing the conclusion at the beginning of the film. And as a further consequence of this incredible piece of ineptitude, the film runs out of steam three-quarters of the way through and ends on a rather contrived and unsatisfying fade-out. "But the performances are superb — though Maxwell Reed makes a little too ludicrous a lover — as is the photography by Reginald Wyer, the seedy sets of art director James Carter, and the astute film editing of Helga Cranston and Peter Pryor."

malcolmgsw According to Quinlan this film was held back from release for 2 years because of problems with the censor.Since producers normally worked in co operation with the BBFC this does seem rather strange.Watching the film now and comparing it say with No Orchids For Miss Blandish it is difficult to understand what problems might have arisen.A more likely reason is the sheer grimness of this film.If it was made in 1945 it was hardly likely to appeal to an audience who had only recently been under attach from V2 weapons.So presumably the producers put it on the shelf waiting for a more appropriate moment to show.The film starts with Portman as the hangman approaching the cell of a condemned man and the mood goes down from there,if that is possible.The story is rather a mess and the pairing between Portman and Todd unlikely in the extreme.The ending is about as downbeat as you will ever find.Definitely not a film I would ever wish to see again!

Alex da Silva Eddie (Eric Portman) is a hangman, who makes a confession when he comes face to face with his final victim, Olaf, (Maxwell Reed). He tells the story of how he knows the victim to the Governor (Milton Rosmer). We learn of Eddie's double life - he uses an alias and has a share in a hairdresser business with Ron (Bill Owen). We follow the story as he inherits a fleet of barges and meets with Frankie (Ann Todd). They marry and settle down on a barge where Eddie hires Olaf as a workman...The cast are quite good despite some appalling accents. Eric Portman delivers a mish-mash of a southern/northern accent and God knows what planet Maxweel Reed thought Danish people come from! My favourite in the cast is actually Jane Hylton who has a small role as "Doris" the barmaid. It's a shame that more of a role wasn't given to her.With regards to the relationships between the characters, why didn't Eddie and Frankie just come clean with each other? He doesn't tell her of his role as a hangman and she doesn't mention anything to him about her fear of Olaf. This leads us to believe that maybe she had a previous job as a prostitute and maybe she loves it. She certainly has an independent streak as we see this on her first meeting with Eddie. I also felt that Eddie is too old for Frankie and his marriage proposal to Frankie and her acceptance after their 3rd meeting is laughable. The film has a very downbeat ending and my girlfriend cried - not because of any affiliation to any particular character but purely because of the film's atmosphere. It's bleak.

calvertfan Daybreak is totally fascinating - the kind of movie you can stare at, open mouthed, for the full hour and a half. Ann Todd as always is wonderful, but this has to be one of her best performances by far. Apparently a lot of the movie was cut by the censors upon its release leaving gaps in the story, and you do get this sense at least with Todd's character - there's a slight hint that she may have been a prostitute but this isn't followed through and is just forgotten.Without spoiling the ending - and don't read the plot summary before you see the film! - this is one of the most heartbreaking shows of misunderstanding ever. Todd lives with husband Eric Portman on a barge and his business sends him away for long periods of time, leaving her along with the very seedy Norwegian "Olaf", and leaving it up to the audience to guess what he does to her. One night she begs her husband to stay, or take her with him, but he can't, and yet she won't tell him why. He comes home and finds Olaf present, but unfortunately gets the wrong idea about why he is there.It's a shame so much was cut from this fine film, but what is left is sufficient to garner it a 10/10. The scene especially where Todd and Portman meet is an utter delight!