Diagonaldi Very well executed

Lollivan It's the kind of movie you'll want to see a second time with someone who hasn't seen it yet, to remember what it was like to watch it for the first time.

Orla Zuniga It is interesting even when nothing much happens, which is for most of its 3-hour running time. Read full review

Mathster The movie runs out of plot and jokes well before the end of a two-hour running time, long for a light comedy.

theoshul DON GIOVANNI as a Blaxploitation-gangster flick (or an episode of KOJAK or Miami VICE)! You'll love it or you'll hate it. Elizabeth Schwarzkopf hated it and said Peter Sellars should be in prison for doing it. I loved it. And I think Mozart would have loved it too--he almost always went out of his way to make his work appealing to ordinary people.Besides the modern 1970s/1980s TV-type staging and casting and costumes, this performance is excellent musically AND dramatically. More than most performances it shows the interactions between the characters, and the passions they feel. Some of the nuances are subtle, for instance, in the Act 2 trio where the Don re-seduces Donna Elvira ("Ah taci, ingiusto core"), when the Don sings about how talented he is at seduction ("Piu fertile talento del mio no non si da!"), his face registers distress, not pride or triumph. In normal performances he's exulting in his skill; here he's lamenting that he can only receive love by USING his skill.

TheLittleSongbird Don Giovanni is one of my all-time favourite operas, and while I don't think this is the best Don Giovanni, it was very enjoyable. I think those who don't like Mozart tampered with will not like this production, however on its own merits coming from someone who tries to be not so fussy about all that depending on whether the staging in accordance to the tone of the opera.Even with the update to the 20th century and Harlem NYC, this updating actually worked in my view. It still had the darkness, excitement and thrills the opera should do. The staging was very imaginative, particularly in the Commendatore scene and Giovanni's descent into hell and the champagne aria being sung in a garage with Giovanni slinging bottles against the door before taking heroin. The rape at the start is shocking and bold, but for me set the tone of the production quite well.Production-wise this Don Giovanni is also very good. It maintains the darkness the score suggests with atmospheric lighting and strong costumes and sets. I did find that Giovanni and Leporello dressed in identical black jackets was a little confusing and muddied at first, but I got used to it.It is excellent musically too. Mozart's score is perhaps his darkest and most complex and it needs a very good orchestra and authoritative conductor, both of which this Don Giovanni has.The picture quality is mostly good with some average moments when viewed for example on a projector for a large screen. The sound is clear, and the camera work shows skill and thought.The principals are excellent. Don Giovanni is closer to the narcissistic, sociapathic rapist he should be, and Leporello is loyal and charming. Both characters are played excellently by Eugene and Herbert Perry. Both the acting and singing are great by both, if sometimes in need of a little more intensity.Dominique Labelle is impressive as Donna Anna, it is a very musical interpretation, she is suitably fiery and her singing has style, beauty and agility. I would also say the same for Lorraine Hunt, who not only gives Elvira spite but also development, I consider Elvira the opera's heart and this was done very well.Ai Lan Zhu's Zerlina is adorable not to mention charming. Massetto is good especially in the acting, and the Commendatore is genuinely imposing in the final scene. The only principal who doesn't quite convince is Carrol Freeman's Ottavio. The acting is acceptable, but the voice is too soft and he struggles with some of the runs.Overall, very enjoyable. 9/10 Bethany Cox

Framescourer A brave attempt to assimilate the idea and story of Mozart's masterwork into the 1980's. It has inherent value in the decision to cast twins as the strange doppelganger of Leporello and the Don and of course the arresting setting of the whole opera in contemporary urban America.There is a problem for me and a quite significant one at that; a surly lack of good humour. The characterisations become monochromatic. Love and forgiveness begin to feel like last resorts as a result. An interesting and watchable shift in this respect is the increased importance of Donna Elvira (the mercurial Lorraine Hunt Lieberson).Key to Sellars' recording is that it is intended specifically for film, with no attempt to play to an auditorium. This makes it more idiomatic on-screen, although as I say, surly and introverted. Bold and flawed. 4/10

Dennette Peter Sellars has taken Mozart's "Don Giovanni" and set it in modern New York City ... and it still works, which just goes to show how timeless the genius of Mozart really is. But Sellars true genius was in casting African-American twins to play the parts of Don Giovanni and his servant, Leporello ... there is a scene where they change places, disguised as each other, and you don't have to suspend your disbelief to enjoy it. There is a scene where they discuss their plans for the evening over a meal ... the fact that they are sitting on a curb eating burgers from McDonalds does not get in the way at all.For any inner-city teacher who would like to introduce their students to opera, seeing two vital, young black males singing music that's 200 years old, and in Italian (with English subtitles), should be an eye-opening experience. The multiracial cast showcases many splendid young (and at the time, unknown) voices selected only for their talent, and demonstrates that opera is really for everyone.I'm glad that I taped it from PBS years ago, because it hasn't been released yet on VHS or DVD. <sigh!>