Ensofter Overrated and overhyped

ReaderKenka Let's be realistic.

GazerRise Fantastic!

Sameer Callahan It really made me laugh, but for some moments I was tearing up because I could relate so much.

MikesIDhasbeentaken Yes the maker of this doc is a family member of one of the accused, and although 7 were convicted, this focuses on just the one family member, who does get special treatment because he's a member of a more wealthy family and a Spanish citizen. However, even after looking up the case i can't see any major evidence this doc left out, there was pretty much no evidence to convict him, and the corruption was so obvious it's crazy. This isn't a 'Jinx' or 'making a murder', where your left questioning if they done it or not, this is pretty obvious he did't do it, this is about showing how bad the country was at the time of the murder. There's just so much here thats crazy, paying people to testify, the judge saying there's 'to many' witnesses to him not being near the crime scene, promotions to law enforcement ppl who testified, immunity and 'gifts' to the testifying co-offender, the judge turning up dead after not sentencing them to death, not caring whose body was actually found (so they never actually found either body of the victims), the president being found guilty of corruption, the re-enactment that was broadcast..It's all crazy, the public demanded blood and the corrupt state done their best to supply it. A great documentary to watch in the knowledge that however corrupt and wrong you think things are, it's not as bad as this!

stevendecastro Click "Yes" below if you are on the side of the rape victims and their family! It almost happened before. In September 1996, according to the Philippine Supreme Court decision G.R. Nos. 138874-75, the parents of a girl named Rochelle wrote a letter of complaint against teenager Paco Larranaga, stating that Rochelle was at the side of the road when Larranaga pulled up in a car full of teenage boys, and "grabbed Rochelle by her hand to try to get Rochelle to their vehicle. She resisted and got away from him. Sensing some people were watching what they were doing, they hurriedly sped away." Nevertheless, nothing was done because Larranaga was the son of a wealthy connected family, and the children of the rich usually get their way in the Philippines.A few months later, Larranaga and seven of his friends raped and killed two girls, by abducting them in a van they had rented for the occasion. In an extended trial in which both sides presented hours of testimony, and numerous appeals, the Philippine courts found Paco and his friends guilty of kidnapping, rape and murder.Although the Larranaga family lost in court, they are winners at the film festivals. Take away the exciting musical score and fast cutting, and the film boils down to this: the Philippines justice system is corrupt, and therefore Larranaga didn't rape anybody.I am a lawyer who has often stood up for the wrongly accused. Even before I checked out the evidence for myself, I suspected that he was guilty, just from watching the movie and tuning out the hype. I think what the film goers should remember is that two innocent women were raped and killed, and they are as vulnerable to the arbitrariness of the Phil justice system as Larranaga. Several witnesses placed Larranaga in the van with the other rapists, and I think that the rich kid's army of alibi witnesses don't count for much when you check their testimony. (By the way, I am not anti-rich. My family owns a lot of land in the Philippines.)Incredibly insulting was the conscious effort of the producers to portray Larranaga's family members as disinterested and victimized by the government, while vilifying the mother and father of the real victims to be liars who desperately want the wrong man to go to prison, based on what I thought was a nonsensical theory. The theory is that the Chiong family wants to frame Paco to prevent police from discovering that the daughters were killed by criminals who their father was doing business with. What the gullible international audience doesn't understand is that there is no reason for a person to deflect attention in a murder investigation, because in the Philippines, most murders go unsolved. And besides, the Larranagas are claiming that a father would rather continue to do business with criminals after they raped and killed BOTH of his daughters! I would say that this is insulting the public's intelligence, but based on the reviews, most of the public bought it. Perhaps it is just a prejudice that no one believes that the Philippine government could ever get anything right (I find it hard to believe too, but it is true in this case.) But the one place where this film was not well received was in Cebu, where the events took place. Filipinos know their system is corrupt, but they also know that their daughters are safer with the rapists in jail.This is a very good case study for the successful use of unethical pseudo-journalistic practices in documentary filmmaking. To top it off, one of the producers is part of Larranaga's wealthy clan, and I think it would have been fairer to disclose that at the beginning, not the end, of the movie.

brusty1 I saw this film two years ago as a secret screening at the True/False Film Festival. It was easily my favorite documentary that year, and one which will leave you disturbed long after the credits have rolled. The film outlines the arrest and conviction of Paco Larranaga and several other young men in the murder of two young girls. As the director peels the layers back on the story, more and more you see how the entire situation is a complete miscarriage of justice. This film will leave you feeling not unlike the Paradise Lost documentaries about the West Memphis Three. As someone who is poor and has little to no power, I implore anyone reading this to watch the film, get involved and help free a young man who had absolutely nothing to do with these crimes. I urge you to do your own research if you are skeptical, as some might think because the director is related to the convicted man. I watch documentaries with an avid passion, but few have left me so emotional as Give Up Tomorrow. A must see!

dbborroughs This is one of the best films I've seen this year. It's also the most important film I've seen.The film is the story of Paco Larranaga. He was arrested and convicted, along with six other people, for the kidnap and murder of the Chong sisters. The body of one of them (possibly, maybe it was her body) was found at the bottom of a ravine. The people in the country were horrified and the persons responsible had to be found.The trouble was they got the wrong guys.First off it wasn't clear whose body was found. Next, most of the people arrested never met before and they were supposed to have gang-raped the girls. The real kicker was that Paco, supposed leader of the group, could be proved via photographs, official records and eyewitness testimony to be 350 miles away at the time of the kidnapping and murder. No one ever looked into the fact that the girl's father had broken with his boss, and was going to testify against him. Oh yeah, and the boss was a well known drug dealer with connections to people in the police and government, and once the girls went missing the father changed his mind about testifying.There's more; a lot more. More than you can ever imagine. The film has revelations from start to finish and it gets so that you almost feel like you're drowning. This film will blow your mind at how wrong things can go and how stupid, blind, and corrupt people will be. And trust me, after 95 minutes your mind will be blown.I was horrified. I was shaking.This insanity has been going on for 17 years...and it's still not over with, because a development that was supposed to free Paco is actually keeping him in prison with a truly mind boggling Kafka-esque twist.This is a film that lays out clearly why this case is the new definition of miscarriage.This is a must see film on any number of levels. On one level it's a good, if horrifying story; on another it's a film that will spur you to take action; and lastly this will make you thankful that most of the world's justice systems are not this horribly out of whack.I don't know what else to say. You need to see this film; yes because it's good, but also because this sort of thing can not be allowed to happen to anyone anywhere.