pointyfilippa
The movie runs out of plot and jokes well before the end of a two-hour running time, long for a light comedy.
Lidia Draper
Great example of an old-fashioned, pure-at-heart escapist event movie that doesn't pretend to be anything that it's not and has boat loads of fun being its own ludicrous self.
Lachlan Coulson
This is a gorgeous movie made by a gorgeous spirit.
edohanclasen
I really enjoyed watching this film.Reading the synopsis beforehand I expected it to be kind of a low budget comedy with lots of corny, expected jest of a old lady trying to allure a younger man. Although the movie did have some of these elements, it beautifully dramatized the life of Doris Miller (Sally Field) in a way one can relate to. The age difference between Doris and John Fremont (Max Greenfield, an actor I have been fond of since I saw him as Schmidt in New Girl) is portrayed in a very unique way. In particular the film exploited the almost ridiculousness of modern 'hipster' notions. In several scenes Doris is sketched as a real-life thrift shop and the mere fact that Doris is old attracts and amuses Fremont and his friends.Apart from the main plot that follows Doris' attempts to impress Fremont, it also has some deep character development in Doris. Overcoming her mother's death (Doris took care of her for several years) and having to get rid of some of her mom's belongings, and at the same time handle her demanding siblings, Doris discovers that there is several things in her life that makes her unhappy. While in this turmoil with Fremont it also helps her overcome this personal problems.I would recommend this film to anyone looking for an easy-watching, congenial and relaxing comedy that is not the same as the normal slapstick, predictable comedies doing the rounds nowadays.
Caleb Whitney
I have to start by saying that Sally Field's performance is truly Oscar-worthy. In fact, all of the performances are stellar. The main character, played with perfect pitch by Field, is truly disgusting and frightening. Oddly, the film portrays this lying, manipulative hoarding stalker as a sympathetic character, which she is not. (The following editorial contains spoilers as it summarizes the fate of Doris) Doris should have been punished for being a hoarder and for interfering with her co- worker's personal life. The writers should have shown what happens when destructive, dangerous stalkers bother normal people. I would have given the film a 10 if John had given her a harsh beat down or even murdered her for her transgressions. I think in New York it might be legal to shoot a person who cyber stalks you. Don't take my word for it though as I am not an attorney. I was disbarred years ago and am not at all qualified to give legal advice. For all I know it could be totally illegal to shoot people in NY unless you're a drug dealer or a police officer. Word of advice to the filmmakers: In the real world, John would only be interested in a crazy cat lady lying stalker if he himself were seriously disturbed, so in a sequel it would be good to explore John's dark, perverted, cat lady fetish having, murderous side. Also, I believe it is irresponsible to send such a dangerous message to unbalanced viewers who may feel the film validates their delusions. The Dangerous message is: If you lie, cheat, stalk and steal from your victim, he will love you, even if you're a filthy, smelly unbathed pig who lives in a garbage house. Why? Because you are the center of the universe and others are just props in your play. The more responsible message would be: People like Doris are dangerous and stupid and deserved to be pushed in front of a subway train.Finally, am I alone in my perception that the film strongly implies Doris killed her mother?
soleilangela
I thought this was a comedy. Turned out it was very sad and kept me up all night as I was so upset about this poor old lady being in humiliating situations so many times. I found it to be a heartbreaking movie that made it appear as though love between an older lady and a younger man could not be possible. The old lady was very attaching and I loved her. She played her role beautifully. I just do not see what is funny about this movie, unless you like to laugh at vulnerable old ladies.
Mark F.
Short and simple, I loved it. It needs a sequel if not an HBO or SHO series!So many poignant moments in this film, especially Doris at a mirror later in the film after John rejected here. And joy and craziness. Sally Field displayed an Olympic range of emotions with one of her best-ever performances.Alas, the ending leaves one wishing for more. HBO or SHO could pick up this ball and run with it. What does Doris do for housing, work, dating (hopefully not with "Uncle Frank." A decisively happy continuing story line for Doris would be magic.
