Humaira Grant It’s not bad or unwatchable but despite the amplitude of the spectacle, the end result is underwhelming.

Calum Hutton It's a good bad... and worth a popcorn matinée. While it's easy to lament what could have been...

Sarita Rafferty There are moments that feel comical, some horrific, and some downright inspiring but the tonal shifts hardly matter as the end results come to a film that's perfect for this time.

Jemima It's a movie as timely as it is provocative and amazingly, for much of its running time, it is weirdly funny.

Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de) The title "Noah's Ark" from this animated short film we have here tells you of course already what it is about, namely the biblical tale of Noah and his family being safe from an apocalyptic flood on a ship and they are joined by all kinds of animals, 2 of each species. This short film here is from 1959, which means it is almost 60 years old, and runs for 21 minutes. So it is the final days/years of the Golden Age of Animation and everybody was clearly looking for new approaches. Several of the other reviewers said that this does not look like Disney at all and they could not be more correct. But it is Disney and to me it looked very European, like some of the Soviet animation from that period. But the fact that it looks different doesn't mean at all it is bad. The writer, director and the voice cast, including the singers, all did a pretty good job here and honestly it really won't take you even five minutes to get used to the looks of this little film. Besides, it's decent story-wise too. With random fun focus on some occasions like the plot about the womanizer hippo (by the way, where were the other animals' men), they also never forgot what the key story is about and so you get the basics like the bird near the end. And there is as much love to detail as in many other more known Disney productions. One example would be the cleaning birds or whatever their ornithological name may be sitting on these crocodiles when the enter the ark. So yes, overall this is a good watch. Open yourself to new things and you won't be bothered by the looks of this Oscar-nominated film at all. I personally think I'd even have preferred it to win over the Hubley short that triumphed back then. I recommend this version of Noah's Ark. Thumbs up!

TheLittleSongbird And that's more to do with how truly unique it is rather than being one of their best, at the top of my head there is no other Disney short like Noah's Ark. And that is mainly down to the animation style and the creativity gone into the characters, in many ways Noah's Ark is very different for Disney but that's not a bad thing here. Noah's Ark doesn't have the most compelling of stories, the story itself is rather thin on the ground and the pacing lags at times. But the reason why Noah's Ark rates high personally is because, despite the story being unexceptional, everything else works brilliantly. The stop-motion animation immediately reminds one of Rankin'/Bass rather than the traditional hand-drawn animation usually seen with Disney at this time, but it does look very charming and beautiful with some clever stylised designs and some of the visuals are a huge amount of fun to watch, still holding up by today's standards. What helps Noah's Ark immensely is George Bruns' jazzy score, which is so energetic and wonderfully upbeat, Mrs. Hippo's song has some very witty lyrics too. The songs are all very sprightly and drive the short really well. Noah's Ark has a touch of weirdness, meant in a good way, and even more immense charm. Jerome Courtland's narration is effective in how simple it is and Jeanne Cayle does some great vocals too, but even better is Paul Frees, known as one of the best voice actors of the time and judging from his brilliant voice work here that's justified. It's the work done with the household items and the animals though where Noah's Ark really excels, it's a hard job making household items creative(using them to build the animals) and interesting but Noah's Ark does it and does so ingeniously. The cork hippos are especially delightful. Overall, a unique Disney short and a good one. 8/10 Bethany Cox

MartinHafer This is a super-strange and highly creative short from Disney--and it looks nothing like a Disney production. That's because it is NOT hand-drawn animation but stop-motion! Well, evidently, the Oscar people liked it, as they nominated this film for Best Animated Short.The story is a pretty traditional retelling of the story of Noah's Ark. However, it includes peppy music (Dixieland, jazz and rock 'n roll) and VERY weird animals. That's because there is no attempt to make them look realistic! The animals consist of various objects, such as funnels, bottles, eggs, pipe cleaners, corks, pencils and other strange materials. It's weird but also pretty cool how they were able to use the materials the way they did. You just have to see it to believe it.

Robert Reynolds This cartoon was nominated for an Oscar in 1959. The animation style is stop-motion, almost a Puppetoon type of animation. This is the only cartoon from Disney that I recall ever seeing. It certainly is not your typical Disney cartoon. The music is all over the board-there's even some pretty good blues in here. Worth chasing down to see at least once. Runs infrequently on the Disney Channel during "Vault Disney" in the wee hours of the morning.