IslandGuru Who payed the critics

Tedfoldol everything you have heard about this movie is true.

2freensel I saw this movie before reading any reviews, and I thought it was very funny. I was very surprised to see the overwhelmingly negative reviews this film received from critics.

Brooklynn There's a more than satisfactory amount of boom-boom in the movie's trim running time.

ronchow I stumbled upon this film in my search for more films in the Kwaidan genre. The DVD quality was OK but after viewing the film, I kind of understand why it was not more popular as a film, although it also came from the same time period when ghost stories - Kwaidan, Strange Tales from the Four Valleys - basically introduced me to the joy of Japanese cinema in my younger years.It is nutshell, it was a slow and tedious film without a character that you would care about. Well, perhaps except the daughter of the protagonist, played by Tatsuya Nakadai. He was one of my favourite Japanese actor from the past and his acting here was fairly solid. Still, it did not compensate enough for the pace and dullness of the story line.Perhaps this story is more suited for a stage play. For cinema, much is lacking to make the film engaging to its audience.

chaos-rampant No one does 'descent into madness and despair' better than Tatsuya Nakadai. And when it comes to theatrical lighting, expansive settings, and slow-fi supernatural poetics, no one does them better than the Japanese, who had the benefit of a few centuries of kabuki experience before Mario Bava and Roger Corman got there with their cobwebs and color filters. All the elements are in place then and Shiro Toyoda delivers with utmost impunity. In part a not-so-distant cousin of the kaidan genre of spooky ghost stories that proliferated all through the first half of the 60's in Japan, complete with deformed ghostly apparitions that come and go as they please, yet also a bit of a prestige film that can afford beauty for beauty's sake without having to cram plot points in the short running time of a second-bill film, this reflected in the stars of the film (Tatsuya Nakadai and Kinnosuke Nakamura) and the lush sets Toho Studios put in Toyoda's disposal, the vivid colors and accomplished camera-work that suggest a director more talented than his nonexistent reputation in the West implies, all these elements coming together to create a dramatically unsubtle, not really horrifying but tragic and macabre, parable on the unyielding monomania of a perfectionist. A Korean painter is summoned by his Japanese lord to paint a portrait of Buddhist heaven. The Japanese lord becomes smitten by the painter's daughter and takes her for his concubine. The Korean painter pleads for his daughter, this coming across as more the whim of a possessive father than genuine love. Finally he settles for painting a portrait of hell. You just know Tatsuya Nakadai's face is gonna be a mask of utter despair and torment by the end and it's worth the ride getting there because the conclusion is truly ferocious.

Frances Farmer Let me start off by saying I love Japanese cinema, literature and culture generally. I've seen many Japanese movies and enjoyed them, but "Portrait of Hell" (aka Jigokuhen) makes itself ridiculous. The two characters who dominate the action -- the "evil lord" in his privileged bubble and the "stubborn, crazy artist" are pure types with zero subtlety or nuance, and all their actions emanate from cartoonish extremes. The film wants to show horrible scenes of violence and raw emotion but many of these scenes are so over the top they actually become laughable and the overall feeling is that of a made-for-TV movie that went off the rails. If this rarely screened movie falls in your hands or comes to your town, spare yourself and give it a pass.

EVOL666 I knew nothing about PORTRAIT OF HELL when I gave it a shot, and I'm glad of that now. An interesting tale of the consequences of greed, pride, stubbornness, and racism - all told through the story of an artist and an emperor. The story takes place at a time in feudal Japan where the aristocrats and rulers were rich, but the local people were starving in the streets. This "feast-or-famine" society is the backdrop for the film...Yoshihide is the most talented artist in the area. He's also a stubborn hard-ass who has nothing but contempt for the local ruler - but realizes that he is under his command and thus stays in his "place" for the most part. The Paramount Lord is a greedy and self-centered bastard who thinks he is Gods gift to the world, literally - but understands Yoshihide's talent, and thus let's him get away with a little more than the average citizen. In a strange way, the two have a begrudging "respect" for each other, though they really hate each other's guts. Yoshihide runs off his daughters boyfriend, and during a chance encounter, the Paramount Lord meets her and makes her his concubine. This of course does not sit well with Yoshihide, who begs the Lord for his daughter back. The Lord refuses - unless Yoshihide can paint a suitable mural for his mansion. The Lord wants a portrait of heaven and paradise - whereas Yoshihide wishes to paint a hell-scene, as he is downtrodden by the treatment of the local people. The Lord eventually grants Yoshihide the opportunity to paint whatever he would like, but as the two do battle through words and trickery - the price that either may end up paying may far outweigh the saving of their pride...PORTRAIT OF HELL is a strong film that deals effectively with several subjects at once. Both Yoshihide's and the Paramount Lord's pride and stubbornness ultimately become their downfall - which has always been a fitting lesson. The side-story of Yoshihide's refusal for his daughter to date a non-Korean boy, and the results thereof, is a brief touch on the consequences of racism. But even with all the "moral-of-the-story" type things going on in the film, it never becomes overbearing. PORTRAIT OF HELL is still an entertaining film with a strong "twist" ending that brings everything home. Overall, I would recommend this film to fans of "classic" Asian cinema or those who would just like a break from the norm. Also of note are the beautiful sets, very good acting, and some very decent visual FX for the time-frame. Definitely worth a look - 8.5/10