Neive Bellamy Excellent and certainly provocative... If nothing else, the film is a real conversation starter.

Tyreece Hulme One of the best movies of the year! Incredible from the beginning to the end.

Cody One of the best movies of the year! Incredible from the beginning to the end.

Cassandra Story: It's very simple but honestly that is fine.

imran-khawaja Before I start I would like to state that I loathe conventional Bollywood cinema. I hate the fact that any tension or drama that has(in some very exceptional circumstances) been built up over the course of a scene, can be destroyed by wholly unnecessary dance number. I hate the fact that Indian cinema uses the same formula for all its films and plagiarizes western cinema when it wants to try something new, because its writers are so inherently lacking any form of creativity or originality.My wife begged me to take her to this movie, and I have to say that it's the best Indian film that I have ever had to watch. I liked the colour (subtle green hues), I liked the background music (classical understated), I liked the mood (subdued),I liked the dialogue (believable) and I loved the ending. Its good that a film can just end and leave you to reflect about what you have seen and draw you own conclusions, rather than spoon feed you at the end.So I say, watch this film if you want to see something a little more involving than the usual mix of singing, dancing, violence and overacting.

salhadid This movie doesn't draw the average Bollywood fan in...why? I'll tell you why. This movie lacks crappy acting, crappy songs, with crappy Michael Jackson-esquire choreographed dancing. This movie is one that is on par with Hollywood's best. Honestly, I think it should have been India's nomination for the Oscars (foreign film), but of course, they chose something crappy. A Bollywood movie isn't a Bollywood movie if there's no "love story" thread. But this movie managed to pull off telling one of the best love stories ever in UNDER TWO AND A HALF HOURS (a record for Bollywood), while avoiding the Bollywood cliché. Such a refreshing movie!

AmidalaSkywalker This movie seemed promising: Ajay Devgan, Aishwarya Ray, unhappy Lovestory....but this movie is plain boring. The camera is stable, the settings are...well, they fit the story, which is not a compliment... there are no songs, not even music most of the time. The actors only talk and nothing really happens. The plot is not to bad, since its inspired by a famous story by O'Henry. And since I wanted to know, how it ends, I even stayed on all through these really, really long 2 hrs. It was so depressing! The only good thing is, that it is so short. If you think now, that I don't know what a good movie is made off, there are movies like this, which i really liked, "Telephone" with Whoopi Goldberg is definitely one of them. But this movie is only watchable for fans of Art-house and maybe fans of French Cinema, because it is a lot like that. So if you are neither, stay away!

shariqq This Rituparno Ghosh mis-directed debacle of an attempt has got the worst of every possible thing you can put together in a movie. But then, it's not so bad that you can laugh at it (ala Hello Brother) - it is just a short notch above; where it has not fallen from torture to joke.Premise: Ajay Devgan is a village-boy who comes to Calcutta to borrow some money from friends to start a new business. During his stay there, he pays a visit to Aishwarya Rai, an old flame, now married off to some rich travelling guy. That's it.Acting is pathetic - now that's normal for Aishwarya Rai, but surprisingly true even for Ajay Devgan in this movie. All characters speak in installments, as if it'll make the performance credible for an off-stream movie. It's shot without a lighting technician. Story is a joke. Direction (as in, where is it going?) is non-existent. Sad... really, Sad. If there was a saving grace in the movie, it could have been the teeny bit by Annu Kapoor. But his part is also let out of the movie like the belch after over-eating.Avoid at all costs.My Rating ---> 0.5 of 5