Laikals The greatest movie ever made..!

Rijndri Load of rubbish!!

SoftInloveRox Horrible, fascist and poorly acted

Yash Wade Close shines in drama with strong language, adult themes.

mstxmac My main quibble with this script (and I did love the movie) was at the time I was reading my copy of Richard Harding Davis, "The Notes of a War Correspondent", his description of the battle came from the actor playing Stephen Crane's. RH Davis is worthy of a rousing action movie in his own right. Would have been a great addition to the movie.

denis888 John Milius has proved everybody here that he could do a real master work of art. This is a very good mini series and it is done without false jingoism, without bombastic pathos, without silly pretense, but with a gusto, with real zeal, with real impeccable taste and vigor. John fervently studied the sources and here we see a real candid picture of a very tragic start of Americano-Spanish war of 1898. The casting is so superb that even Mr. Maxwell with his unbeatable Gettysburg would have been jealous. I was very happy to see three of Gettysburg stars here, even four - Tom Berenger, Sam Elliott, Buck Taylor and a cameo of Patrick Gorman. And then, here are also such luminaries as Gary Busey, Chris Noth in his arguably best role and great late Brian Keith as President McKinley. Tom Berenger as Colonel Theodore Roovelt shines all the movie through - he is loud, clumsy, arrogant, funny, sluggish, but also smart, clever, brave, audacious and unmitigated. He is very good in military roles and here Tom proved it again, Sam Elliott is another great asset, his deep resonant voice and cold look make the film very decent. Brad Johnson as Henry Nash is another great victory here, he is cowardly at first, but clever and brave later then. The excellent music, soft humor, deep sympathy to common soldiers, spellbinding scenery, marvelous battle scenes all make this movie a real gem and a real must see for all History fans, like me. I am still under deepest impression. Great job!

thomas-jensen1 I did enjoy the movie a great deal and was able to look past some of the historical errors, (hard for a military historian). One major point is the inclusion of Fredrick Funston in the film. Funston is truly a character worth a film of his own, small town Kansa boy (Iola, Ks) makes good. While he did fight in Cuba it was prior to the Spanish American War. He was recovering from wounds in the US at the time of the war. He did raise a volunteer regiment, the 20th Kansas that later saw action in the Philippines where Funston and Privates Trembly and White of the 20th Kansas all received the Medal of Honor. Funston was later a key player in the great San Fransico earthquake and on the Mexican border prior to WW I. He was slated to command all American forces in WWI when he died suddenly in 1916 in San Antonio. The command then went to Pershing.

tomaz_lazar The Spanish-American war is a relatively little known episode. Though of little military importance, it was politically significant and in several ways marked a turning point in American history. Great topic for a movie, yet in this case the end result falls dismally short of what it could have been.Though only made for television, Milius was clearly trying to create an epic. Despite a promising start the movie is essentially much too long and downright tedious. The film-making is extremely conventional to put it mildly. Worse yet, the entire movie is based on the same old stereotypes typical of patriotic Hollywood war movies copied time and again, in this case all put together in an inflated, unrealistic and grotesque jumble.We have seen it all over and over again, from an ex-outlaw evolving into a good soldier, Sam Elliot as the tough cowboy turned sergeant, evil, cowardly German advisors importing the latest in arms technology. Action is often severely overdone in the manner of Victorian propaganda, with troops reciting Shakespeare in the midst of battle. The absolute high point of this absurdity is the figure of Roosevelt, slinging his revolver faster than Wyatt Earp while heroically leading the charge. There are also darker and not quite so subtle themes where Milius' militant patriotism really brings uncomfortable undertones - most notably two scenes of killing prisoners, which is shown as almost glorified or at least self-explanatory.All in all, severely overdone, overblown and tedious to watch unless you enjoy militant propaganda.