Comwayon A Disappointing Continuation

Quiet Muffin This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

Walter Sloane Mostly, the movie is committed to the value of a good time.

Francene Odetta It's simply great fun, a winsome film and an occasionally over-the-top luxury fantasy that never flags.

gordonl56 "Stosstrupp 1917" 1934This excellent German film is about a battalion of the new "Storm troops" that were being employed on the Western Front in 1917. These units were trained to use infiltration tactics, instead of the human wave attacks that the armies of the time used. They would closely follow a "creeping" artillery barrage, then rush through the Allied lines bypassing any strong-points. These tactics proved highly successful and were used to great effect during trench raids. They were also the main reason for the early German breakthroughs during the German Spring Attacks of 1918.This film follows one of these specialist battalions as they are moved from one trouble spot of the front, to another. They start off battling the French before having to deal with various British, Scottish and Canadian units. Attack and counter-attack is the order of the day here.The non-stop artillery fire is absolutely frightening. All day and all night the shells fall, making everything look like a lunar landscape. The mud, rain, and the masses of unburied dead are all shown here. The only place with any kind of safety for the men is when they are in the deep underground bunkers. And these can become a death trap if there is a direct hit. This film is a polar opposite to films like "All Quiet on the Western Front." While not a flag waver by any means. It has a rather darker tone with the men knowing that death could come at any moment. The use of real munitions can be seen in more than a few scenes. I would be amazed if no one was killed, or seriously hurt during the production. It is hands down the most realistic World War One film about trench warfare I have seen. 118 minutes of hell on earth. Well worth seeing if you can find it.

gudrunh-794-69037 Strosstrupp 1917 is essentially a 107 minute artillery barrage along various sectors of the Western Front; from Champagne to Cambrai via Flanders. It paints a vivid and sobering picture of the ebb and flow of trench warfare in an eerily cratered and water-logged landscape, bereft of everything but the detritus of war.Standing knee-deep for days on end in claustrophobic bunkers. Waiting for an imminent French assault while deprived of food and water. Gas and collapsing shelters.The realism depicted here is made palpable by the use of actual munitions and explosive charges in great number. The randomly heaving and cascading earth, and the rain of mud and debris would have presented very real dangers to the on-screen participants (SA and Wehrmacht extras as well as a handful of professional actors) and production crew alike, such is the proximity of the camera to the action.While the enemy are portrayed with a genuine dignity – the English and Scots in particular - there is one amusing scene which ensues when the German battalion at one stage finds itself surrounded. Two men volunteer to make the perilous trek across French lines in an effort to deliver a vital message to the Regimental HQ. While successful, they are however captured on the return journey and interrogated. A good dose of Gallic bile follows – "Bavarian swine!" – then the obligatory spit, followed by the gullible acceptance of obviously fanciful "intelligence' delivered by our Strosstupp heroes. And then as luck would have it, they manage to escape.This lifting of tension is however all too fleeting.There is one critical piece of dialogue - delivered quite late in the film, which gives it the political clout one would expect. A dying German soldier is being comforted by a comrade:"Please be honest. Tell me, is this a swindle?""A swindle? The war? Oh no, how could you think it's a swindle? We're doing it for our people back home, for your wife and your children, to keep our country from being devastated like Flanders.Your meadows and your fields…if we weren't here your homeland would look like this."But it is upon reading the dead soldier's last letter from home that this concept of a "swindle" is brutally hammered home. Her revelations from the home-front elicit this reaction from the readers:"An MG-42 should fire into the lot of them…something's going on back home, and we're putting our head on the block for that society. They're not really worth it.""We'll have to clean our house when we get home, but we'll have to start at the top, the swindle must be coming from there, otherwise, ordinary people wouldn't talk like that.""I'll be right beside you!"The November treason…the Diktat. Plans to avenge the stab in the back are forming already in the heart of the common man and as the movie concludes, so the viewing audience is exhorted to remember this betrayal. Directed by Hans Zöberlein and based on his own published front-line experiences, Strosstrup 17 was designed to counter the pacifist message of Erich Maria Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front, and Adolf Hitler even penned a brief introduction to the text.According to the movie's liner notes, Zöberlein himself was a member of the 1923 Munich Putsch and went on to become a Werewolf leader at war's end. He was sentenced to death for the murder of Penzburg's socialist mayor on April 28, 1945, but that sentence was commuted, and he served a prison term until 1958.He died in 1964.The importance of this movie is derived more from its authenticity and visual power than from its obvious propaganda message. Worthwhile.