Tedfoldol everything you have heard about this movie is true.

Beystiman It's fun, it's light, [but] it has a hard time when its tries to get heavy.

CrawlerChunky In truth, there is barely enough story here to make a film.

Staci Frederick Blistering performances.

kimberlycartercpa-704-787241 The delightful documentary of author Sholem Aleichem is told by Jewish historians using rare archival photos and records. The film explores Jewish culture in 19th century pre-Revolutionary Czarist Russia through the eyes of characters cleverly created by Sholem Aleichem. Protagonists such as Menahem-Mendl, Tevye the Milkman, and Mottel the Cantor's son form the basis of the acclaimed movie Fiddler on the Roof. The author brilliantly spins Yiddish tales of tradition, loyalty, and change at a time of unrest, uncertainty, and anti-Semitism.After watching the Sholem Aleichem documentary, I view Fiddler on the Roof with a deeper, more reflective perspective. I now understand the meaning of the three daughters and how change truly impacted the lives of Russian Jews. Topol played Tevye in the London stage production and Zero Mostel played Tevye in the Broadway production. After viewing Zero Mostel in his Broadway performance it was clear that Topol was the ideal choice to play God's long-suffering servant ("I know, I know. We are Your chosen people. But, once in a while, can't You choose someone else?").My favorite quote in my favorite movie is when Motel tells Tevye of his love for Tzeitel and his intention to marry her. Tevye negates this by telling him he is just a poor tailor. Motel responds "That's true, Reb Tevye, but even a poor tailor is entitled to some happiness! " This says to me that even the least among us deserves to be happy. Interestingly, Leonard Frey, the actor that depicted Motel, was a colorful personage that portrayed a gay character in the stage production and movie Boys in the Band one year before Fiddler in 1970. Sadly, Frey died of complications of AIDS in 1988. Another great voice silenced before his time.I highly recommend Sholem Aleichem: Laughing in the Darkness. It provides a thumbnail sketch of life as a Russian Jew during the late 1800's. The citizens endured turbulent and difficult lives and the movie provides yet another piece of Jewish history in the complete puzzle of life.

MartinHafer This biography and discussion of the work of Sholom Aleichem is very well made. However, you can tell that the filmmaker assumed that only Jewish people would want to watch the documentary, as MANY of the folks being interviewed talk about Jewish traditions or use Yiddish words that a non-Jewish audience would very possibly not understand. I grew up in a Jewish neighborhood and so I know about sitting shiva, shabbat and words like goyim and shtetl. But it seemed very strange that the film did not explain these things (and much more). In fact, there are probably many Jewish people who have lost contact with their Jewishness who don't understand everything these experts say. It's a shame, as Gentile audiences would benefit from learning about Sholem Aleichem as well--especially since "Fiddler on the Roof" (made up of various stories by Aleichem and starring his character 'Tevya') was a hugely popular film embraced by a wide audience, not just Jews. It's really a shame, as the documentary was otherwise exceptionally well made and interesting. Because of this, I give it a qualified recommendation.

lynnfriedman Have you ever wondered if anyone will remember J.K. Rowling in the next century? Hard to believe that Harry Potter could ever fade from the popular consciousness and require a promulgating documentary. Case in point, Sholem Aleichem, the pen name of Solomon Naumovich Rabinovich, a renowned Yiddish author and playwright. His chosen name is a Yiddish variation the expression shalom aleichem, meaning "hello", or "peace be with you" in Hebrew.The musical Fiddler on the Roof was based on one of his many stories about Tevye the Milkman. This was the first commercially successful English-language play about Jewish life in the shtetls of Eastern Europe. Born in 1859 in the Russia Empire, Solomon Rabinovich's father was a rich merchant with a penchant for gambling. This led to the family's economic downfall. Solomon grew up to mirror his father's foibles and bring his own family to financial ruins several times. What he had going for him is his vast intelligence and passion to keep the Yiddish language alive. He used his insight into his own psychology to create characters that served as metaphors for larger Jewish cultural issues of assimilation and identity.Rabinovich's granddaughter Bel Kaufman was the author of "Up the Down Staircase", made into a popular film. Fleeing the Russian pograms and debtors his family finally settled in New York in 1914. An estimated 100,000 mourners turned out for his New York funeral in 1916.

David Ferguson Greetings again from the darkness. Typically a documentary on an individual is either presented as a look back at their life or an observation of their lasting impact. Director Joseph Dorman provides both of these PLUS critical reviews and analysis of the writings of Sholem Aleichem, the writer whose work inspired Fiddler on the Roof. It is an absorbing look at who most would consider to be the most famous Yiddish writer and humorist. His work really bridged the gap between the old world Jews and the rapidly changing and evolving modernists from the turn of the 20th century.At times the film plays like a classroom presentation for 8th graders in World History, but look closer and you'll see many fascinating, rare photographs and video. There is even one bit of audio featuring Aleichem himself reading his own words. Mostly we get Alan Rosenberg as the narrator and Peter Riegert as the voice of the readings.What makes this enthralling, interesting and educational are the terrific interviews with Yiddish experts, and the on camera presence of author Bel Kaufman, Aleichem's granddaughter. There is no fluff or filler here. These people provide real insight and analysis and perspective on his life and writings. The photo montage of the funeral procession with 200,000 New Yorkers is a sight to behold.Maybe you have read the original literary work "Tevye the Dairyman". Perhaps you have seen the 1939 film Tevye. Maybe you were fortunate enough to have seen the original Broadway run of "Fiddler on the Roof". Most likely you have seen the 1971 film musical with the great Topol as Tevye. This film points out that the words and message of Aleichem have been twisted and shifted over the years, but there is no questioning the lasting impact and his determination to document ... Tradition!