filippaberry84
I think this is a new genre that they're all sort of working their way through it and haven't got all the kinks worked out yet but it's a genre that works for me.
Kien Navarro
Exactly the movie you think it is, but not the movie you want it to be.
Ginger
Very good movie overall, highly recommended. Most of the negative reviews don't have any merit and are all pollitically based. Give this movie a chance at least, and it might give you a different perspective.
Boris and Natasha Palmer
Watching this film through a historical rear-view mirror reveals plenty of of prophecies.
Nazis managed to predict their own end and most of the movies about it - including the famous rant from Downfall played by the star of Youtube - Bruno Ganz.
The trick to understanding the movie is - reversing key scenes in the right chronological order.
It is unbelievable that German propaganda and censorship allowed this reel (which makes Eisenstein's Ivan Groznyy look like an étalon of subtlety) into theaters of a war-waging Germany.
The best documentary evidence of the utter stupidity of Nazi state, which failed due to the irrational stupidity of its leadership.
Horst in Translation ([email protected])
"Der große König" or "The Great King" is a German movie from 1942 and everybody who knows a bit about history will realize that this was made during the years of World War II in Nazi Germany, so it falls under the category of propaganda film. It is the story of King Frederick II (aka "Frederick the Great") of Prussia and obviously the maker's intention here was to show us the genuine superiority when it comes to military battle and war in an effort to motivate the German population to hang in and believe in the "Endsieg". Of course, things turned out very differently in the years after, but this should not be a matter in this review. The film runs for two hours and was written and directed by Veit Harlan, the man who was also in charge of the infamous "Jud Süß". The cast includes some of the actors who worked on many propaganda films (especially Kristina Söderbaum), possibly Germany's leading female actor at this point. But there are also people like Paul Wegener, who is today mostly known for his early silent film and whose participation in films like this leaves a bit of a stain on his career, even if it is easy to believe that it was all about being a working actor than about promoting this film's message.Then again, I personally must say the reason why I disliked this film was just the lack of really interesting characters, great acting and a convincing story and plot. I did not really care for the political message this film was trying to send to the world and the German population. I may be a bit biased as films about emperors or old kings have never been my preferred genre choice, often because they are much more about the costumes and art direction and set decoration instead of focusing on the characters in a fascinating manner. This is also true for this black-and-white movie. It dragged on really a whole lot occasions and I do not recommend the watch. Thumbs down.
J_J_Gittes
Another Veit Harlan film seen on the big screen from a fine 35mm print, and I am more and more in awe of Harlan's cinematic sensibilities. His films seem made for the cinema and he is an incredibly visceral visual artist. Of course it helps having one of the best cameramen of your time at your disposal. Bruno Mondi's cinematography produces many special moments that had me in their grip from the beginning. If he shows close-ups of faces (think Hollywood of the 30s combined with Eisenstein) or makes one of his tremendous tracking shots (equally effective in enhancing the dynamics on the battle field or zooming in on people). His super-impositions, montage-sequences or the combination of both, like in the incredible closing images of Friedrich's eyes over a rotating windmill. Mondi can't go wrong, and enhances every acting performance – he must have been loved by his actors. Harlan shows his prowess in the combination of different modes of realism and abstraction (for example the Soviet-style montage-sequences) and his vision is never less than monumental while never forgetting that it's the monumentality of moments of human emotions that are at the center of his art. Lots of the scenes are goose-bump inducing, similar to the finale of Jud Süß (1940) when Ferdinand Marian's character gets punished by the evil townsfolk.As for propaganda: it clearly shows that the film had been made under the Nazi dictatorship, in particular during some brief moments in speeches or dialog by Friedrich the Great. BUT - and this is a huge but - I would argue that the film includes much less war-mongering than could be expected, and one could hardly find a film as ambivalent or dialectical made with propaganda ideas in the (political) background, coming from the Soviet Union, England or the United States in 1942. The film as a whole is in my opinion not a piece of Nazi or militarist propaganda, but could actually also be said to have an anti-war message. At least I think it lets the audience decide what to make of the events and the people depicted.What I took from it were horrible and cruel depictions of the evil that is war, focusing on an embittered, isolated and deeply flawed monarch who remains a controversial figure until the end. Otto Gebühr who played King Friedrich II. in over a dozen films from the early 20s onwards, culminating in this film, gives a masterful performance as the titular anti-hero, who can only let his true emotions come into play when he is alone. Positioned between what he sees as the duty to his people and the duty to his ideals, he loses everything he loves in the sacrifice for the Prussian nation. A tragic fate. In the end the film is an honest and depressing tale in the vein of old Shakespearean drama, where good and evil, right and wrong are often difficult to unravel.Surely one of the best films of the decade from one of the best directors. Pompous, self-indulgent, melodramatic, operatic and therefore full of many condensed truths of life, Harlan depicts male characters that are ambivalent to the core. Maybe a forerunner of sorts of masculine angst-fueled films like Gibson's Braveheart, "The Great King" is an existentialist depiction of historical events that directly relates to the times when it was made. In the middle of all the shenanigans, Kristina Söderbaum, Harlan's wife, placed as a seemingly unnecessary addendum, but clearly showing the torment women had to go through in a society that left little space for them. Much could and should be written about such a film (and similar works), but this is only a short commentary born out of the moment.For a glimpse into Harlan's aesthetics I recommend the first minutes of the film uploaded on YouTube where it isn't essential to understand the dialog.
F Gwynplaine MacIntyre
'Der Große König' ('The Great King') was a Nazi propaganda film which won the 1942 Coppa Mussolini prize as the best foreign film released in Italy that year. One assumes that Mussolini's film critics were not completely objective. And yet this movie has excellent production values and a gripping story which (despite its too-long running time) still make it an appealing film for those of us who aren't Nazis.This film recounts the travails of Prussian king Friedrich the Second during the battle of Kunersdorf, when his army were decimated by the Austrian forces. Just when defeat seemed certain, Russia's czar Peter the Great sent reinforcements.When this movie was made, the early victories of Hitler's army were long past ... and it was now starting to look as if Germany might lose the war after all. 'The Great King' was clearly made to inspire German audiences to continue the struggle against overwhelming odds. Despite its odious Nazi agenda, this film is still eminently watchable. The battle scenes are impressive, and Otto Gebühr gives a fine performance in the lead role as Friedrich. There's also a splendid turn by Paul Wegener as the leader of the Russian forces. Wegener was a stiff and very mannered actor, but he manages to turn those traits to his advantage here.Gustav Fröhlich, best known for playing the idealistic youth in 'Metropolis', gives a splendidly earnest performance here as Sergeant Treskow, who violates orders to give a crucial command to his men ... with disastrous results. The propaganda message here is that good Germans shouldn't take the initiative and think for themselves: instead, they should follow the orders of their wise leaders who know what's best for them.Even though this movie is Nazi agitprop, the Third Reich imagery isn't crammed down our throats here the way it is in 'Triumph of the Will'. You can enjoy this movie without feeling any urge to goose-step. But the story could have been told more effectively in a shorter running time. I'll rate 'Der Grosse Konig' 6 points out of 10.
