Keeley Coleman
The thing I enjoyed most about the film is the fact that it doesn't shy away from being a super-sized-cliche;
Matho
The biggest problem with this movie is it’s a little better than you think it might be, which somehow makes it worse. As in, it takes itself a bit too seriously, which makes most of the movie feel kind of dull.
Edwin
The storyline feels a little thin and moth-eaten in parts but this sequel is plenty of fun.
nfouqet
I have just watched this film for the second time after nearly twenty years and it surprised me. I did not find it so intense and dramatic as it seemed to me the first time I saw it. The arias are beautiful, although I am not an opera lover, and the photography is gorgeous.The fault that I found with the film is its rather fast pace that conspires against the development of the characters and the whole drama. The young protegé of Dallayrac (Jose van Dam) goes through some very hard times and, all of the sudden, he is ready for the competition. It could, and would, have been better if the relationship master-pupil between Dallayrac and Jean had be given some more coverage since he (Jean) represents the greatest challenge for the aging master.The final scene where the two tenors face each other in a grand finale is fairly predictable and takes away much of the dramatic climax.Having said this, on a broader outlook it still remains a very nice and moving film, particularly when we put it against most of the films of the last twenty years, full of irrelevant stories, unnecessary bloodshed and foul language, with characters that do not show any redeeming qualities.
beptep
I certainly disagree with the viewer who called this tedium--after all when one can't tell Mahler's Songs of Ruckert from a symphony, he is no music lover! The recurring song ("Ich bin der welt abhanden gekommen") is very meaningful for it is associated with the teacher, a retired performer (brilliantly played by opera star Jose Van Dam). The words of the song translate as " I am lost to the world with which I used to waste so much time. It has heard nothing from me for so long it may well believe me dead." The song concludes with "I live alone in my heaven, in my love, and in my song." I played this film for a class of students whose knowledge of classical music was nil and they liked it. Of course the young leads were attractive and there was some sex in the film. I suggest you view it should you get the chance. It is one of my favorite films, and you really don't need to be knowledgeable in music to like it as long as you like beauty.
gianniz
The kind of film that earns "European films" the bad rap and bad rep the get from a lot of people these days. I had the feeling the film was written to showcase the music, not vice versa. And since you can't write a terribly compelling film about training vocalists, we're trapped into watching seemingly endless camera pans of trees, birds in them chirping ad nauseum, pseudo-profound, meaningful stares between people who have nothing to say to each other, and a Mahler symphony on the sound track that just simply won't go away. A terribly tedious film.
arielview
This film, one of my favorites of all-time, follows a retired opera star, (played by the real-life opera singer, Jose van Dam) and two pupils he agrees to teach after his retirement. When his two pupils must compete against their teacher's arch nemesis Prince Scotti (delectably played by Patrick Bauchau) and his dippy protege Arcas, it immediately becomes a feel-good movie. With gorgeous cinematography, well-written dialogue and the acting capabilities of Anne Roussel and Philippe Volter to carry the show, you don't need to rely on the beautiful music in both the background and the forefront of the story. You don't need to be a die-hard opera nut like myself to enjoy this film, you just need to be able to tolerate a lovely romance set against a stunning backdrop, where the bad guys can only be fought with musical notes. Go see it and tell me what you think.
