Beystiman It's fun, it's light, [but] it has a hard time when its tries to get heavy.

TrueHello Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.

Neive Bellamy Excellent and certainly provocative... If nothing else, the film is a real conversation starter.

Sarita Rafferty There are moments that feel comical, some horrific, and some downright inspiring but the tonal shifts hardly matter as the end results come to a film that's perfect for this time.

Platypuschow The Thing was years ahead of it's day, it was a stupidly original science fiction horror movie that looked amazing and delivered on near every single front.This feature length documentary on the films creation is a decent enough effort though I'd have appreciated an additional 30-60 minutesFeaturing interviews with a select group of cast and crew (Many notable people including Keith David are sadly mising). We hear from the likes of leading man Kurt Russell & the films mastermind horror legend John CarpenterThe documentary covers the movies origins, how several of the special effects were created and the initial public response which alike many cult classics wasn't that favorable.Though The Thing is an outstanding film this documentary simply doesn't cover enough and though I'd say its essential viewing for fans it could/should have been a lot more thorough.The Good:Decent enough interviewsSome interesting storiesThe Bad:Too shortSome stories were too vagueThings I Learnt From This Documentary:Nobody has the right to be as cool as Kurt Russell

poe-48833 Superb look back featuring most of the major players, from the producers (who are rarely to be found in such documentaries) to the "talent" (the actors). THE THING is one of the few genuinely MYSTERIOUS movies that draws you in from the opening moments (the chase across the snow) and manages to hold you riveted until the final fade out- thanks primarily to director John Carpenter. (It's amazing to me that no one's written a detailed biography of Carpenter: surely his insights into low budget movie-making alone would be worthy of study- not to mention his childhood forays into filmmaking and self-publishing and his work on the Academy-Award winning short, THE RESURRECTION OF BRONCHO BILLY.) (Better still: Carpenter's AUTOBIOGRAPHY would be even better...)

TBJCSKCNRRQTreviews On the DVD of The Thing you'll find this making-of documentary, that was put together almost twenty years later. While this does indulge in the silly gimmick of every chapter name utilizing the title card of the film itself, it is an excellently put together, very entertaining and quite informative piece. It consists of interviews with cast and crew, both groups having plenty to say and being a joy to listen to, behind-the-scenes footage, concept art/examples of how stuff did look or could have and finally clips from the movie, as well as from a couple of others. A specific highlight is Rob Bottin, whose hard work(and I mean that, he actually went to the hospital from exhaustion after they wrapped) helped make the piece as amazing as it was and is. He did just about all of the special effects, and he's a blast to listen to and watch. A comic book fan who was in his early twenties when he worked on the production, he's got a certain manic enthusiasm to him. He is a lot of fun, for both the anecdotes and the breakdown of some of what he created. In general you get to hear a lot about how it was on set, and how they achieved the many tricky aspects. It never becomes too technical to follow for people who don't live and breathe Hollywood, and it never lingers too long. Coming in at 83 minutes, feature-length, almost an hour and a half, this manages to remain worth the energy and time spent on it, throughout. The pacing is spot-on. There is a little love-fest going on, but mostly, it stays on point. I would say that for anyone into John Carpenter and this of his directorial efforts in particular, this alone is reason enough for getting the disc. I recommend this to any fan of him, anyone else who was employed on it, and the silver screen release itself. 10/10

Stephen R. Taylor As a huge fan, since its release, of John Carpenter's now-classic "The Thing," I was ecstatic to find out that this was included in the DVD version of the movie, but I have to admit that I was also disappointed as well. There'd been a rumor for nearly two decades (perpetrated by Fangoria magazine) that the brilliant Rob Bottin had actually made much more of a dynamic final scene than the one we now see, but that Carpenter had "chickened out" and cut alot of it at the last minute. So, I figured this documentary would show the "real" ending, especially since the DVD box advertized that there were "deleted scenes." Alas, all you see, when it comes to that final scene, is some home-movie footage of a tiny model being animated by the stop-motion process. I guess we'll never know if that rumor was true or not. Oh well, as stated above, the doc as a whole is still wonderful, with Director Carpenter, star Russell, and several others of the cast and crew, reminiscing and recanting. Rob Bottin rules!!!