Reptileenbu Did you people see the same film I saw?

Sharkflei Your blood may run cold, but you now find yourself pinioned to the story.

Tobias Burrows It's easily one of the freshest, sharpest and most enjoyable films of this year.

Sarita Rafferty There are moments that feel comical, some horrific, and some downright inspiring but the tonal shifts hardly matter as the end results come to a film that's perfect for this time.

Amy Edwards I was a little girl when the real trial of OJ Simpson for the murders of his wife Nicole and Ron Goldman took place. I don't have much memories of it but I know how it kept the country and the world completely addicted for most a year.I've watched a lot of footage about that case including the great ESPN documentary 'OJ: Made in America' so don't mind me if I compare the two as they were released within months of each other. Let's begin with the good points first. The overall performance of the cast is spot on. They added some drama in their play to make it more excited but it was pretty accurate in general. I was particularly amazed by Sarah Paulson, Courtney B.Vance and Sterling K.Brown. Those 3 really nailed it. They brought a touch of empathy to the real people they are impersonate in the show as we follow them behind the scenes and discover a new side of them. Sarah deserved her Emmy for her performance as Marcia Clark. I remember how Marcia looked like an Iron lady when she took the stand but Sarah made her more vulnerable than she looked and I take this as a big plus. When I see the real Marcia getting interviewed, I feel this side of her and it's good to see.The rest of the cast is not bad either except for Cuba Gooding Jr and John Travolta who I truly think were far from being the best choice to play the part of OJ and Shapiro but I will talk about this later on alongside another issue.I also liked how the trial itself was accurately presented. You can feel a lot of research has been done to make it look like as real as possible. Of course you can't expect any suspense in that show as we all know how it turned out. I wish we could have seen the Goldmans more often especially how they are coping with the death of their beloved son instead of Rob Kardashian and his family who is appearing way too often without bringing anything. The Goldman and Browns would have however more than you can imagine.Which brings me to my main issue about this show: Where is Ron Shipp?? For the people who are not very familiar with him, Ron was one of the best friends of OJ and Nicole. He was a member of the LAPD and a close witness of what was happening in their marriage especially the domestic abuse. He's also the one whom Simpson confessed having dreams of killing Nicole. But here in that show, he doesn't appear at all! He's not even mentioned once in the 10 episodes. Not once while he's definitely a center piece of the case. That's something OJ made in America didn't miss as Ron was one of the main part of the cast as he shone the light about what was going on in the Simpson Marriage. They should have made him part of the story as he would have brought so much. Having him completely removed is gross negligence at least for me.Now about Cuba Gooding Jr. He should not have been the one casted for the role of OJ. OJ was charismatic and impressive. He made the show before the camera and he still does today. Cuba is a great actor but he just doesn't have that presence. To be honest he's looking like a pawn in that show. He's also way too small and not as athletic as the real OJ was. If there is one actor who would have been better, it should have been Denzel Washington. He has the charisma and the body. It should have been him.And John Travolta as Robert Shapiro is a complete joke. I truly don't know why they chose such a bad actor to undertake the part of that colorful lawyer. I watched a lot of footage of Shapiro and he never gesticulated in the manner Travolta did, ever. Instead he was someone much restrained in front of the camera, he sure wanted the attention but Travolta, with his grand gesture frenzy makes him look like a clown. To be honest I never had a high opinion of John Travolta and he surely not redeemed himself with that performance. I'd rather say he buried himself a few feet more.But besides that, I would give the show a high mark as it deserves it. It's not perfect but it surely does the job.

hddu10 The death of Versace is one of those "the truth is stranger than fiction" real life dramas that captivated the world. Yet even among the facts at hand, the typical ultra-liberal Hollywood jewry had to spin this in directions to appease the status quo in La-La land. As an example, we see constant baseless digs at the Catholic church (insinuating that this could have been the reason for the whole tragedy in episode 1). And of course, in a story where nearly all the leads are Italian, they are either played by jews or Spanish-speakers (because you know..they're all pretty much alike). While Edgar Ramirez has an almost uncanny resemblance to Gianni and Penelope Cruz captures Donatella's walk and expressions very well, the moment either of them open their mouth it's like watching a bad Almadovar film (hmm...actually, is there a good one?) coupled with a Hollywood caricature. The flow, pace and non-linear story line are superb...it's just a shame the director was clueless on the subject matter.

chicchan Oh man... So sad it's over! Why so short??! Murphy, you are an artist god. I very much loved the second season than the first one. I mean, the OJ's was very good, but not so much has the Versace's. Maybe it's because i'm European, or maybe it's because im used to all the crimes in USA, that we watch in films and on the news, so the OJ's case i always saw it like another "normal" (not normal at all!) us boring thing. Did he did it or Not? And on Versace's case it was always the "why".. which was also the typical young traumatized child, who wasnt loved by one or both is parents/family, who was thought to be a fight dog and who would eventually bite. The psychological level on this season was more intriguing and exciting. Everyone on this season has done an incredible job, and the actors are amazing. Your Cunanan, is impossible to hate... even 'tho we all know what he did..! Versace is a total look-alike. Congrats also to Penelope, she has portrayed a lovely Donnatella.

ronnbro-2 I was so excited and enjoyed the series until the ending because of the made up suicide of Versace's partner. Made me question the whole story. So, every gay person in the film was murdered or killed themseleves. All the gay guys are self-loathing or weaklings or murderers. Why? And this from an out gay producer? There were definitely amazing moments and Emmy deserving acting (Darren Criss, Judith Light, Max Greenfield and Edgar Rameriz) but the final message was so wrong and not truthful. Kind of left me feeling a bit dissed. Worth the journey but not the destination.