Matialth
Good concept, poorly executed.
Ogosmith
Each character in this movie — down to the smallest one — is an individual rather than a type, prone to spontaneous changes of mood and sometimes amusing outbursts of pettiness or ill humor.
Yash Wade
Close shines in drama with strong language, adult themes.
denis888
For a long time, I was rather suspicious about this movie, despite my lifelong interest in the US Civil War theme. The movie seemed to be bland, long, vapid, without stellar cast, or rather grim. Than, I watched it. It lasts for almost 3 hours, and yet, it is one of The best movies I have ever seen for along, long time. This movie must be shown to all those who like to think that was is fun and action. Nope. War is all hell. it is dirt, deprivation, hunger, blood, suffering, angst, death, despair, pain and mud. Thus yellow, think, fat stick yellow mud is a great symbol of the movie and a great reminder of the ultimate destination of all warheads - soil. Grave. Death. The movie is long, but never wastes a second of a precious time. The brilliantly made casting, with such greats as Willaim Macy or Mr. Forrester among many, helps to build a great tension and produce a lasting impression - war is all hell. The terrible fate of Andersonville prison camp inmates is shown so brutally vivid, so real, so true to life that nothing of an illusion remains whatsoever. War is all hell. This is a decent portrayal of sheer pain and tragedy of more than 12 000 Union soldiers who dies there. And those who survived, Who fought and survived. I like this tremendous film, it is Highly Recommended
Venge
Having looked forward to seeing this film for quite a while, I was quite let down when I finally managed to view it. Andersonville is a story that needed to be told, but this telling of the tale rattles and rambles trying to find its sense of direction. The production suffers from a rather poorly written script and mediocre acting. There were some decent scenes, and a few good performances, but by and large this was a rather jumbled, boring, over-long, predictable mess. It could have been, and deserved to be, so much more.So unless you really have to see a movie about this notorious prisoner of war camp, I'd give this one a miss.
dcheek56
I believe this is one of the best and most fair-minded Civil War movies ever made. The actors all give a first-rate performance, and the director keeps the movie focused and on track, without laying blame to either side. Most of the movies facts are historically accurate and the dialog reproduces (in my opinion) the attitudes of the times.The Raiders were a historical reality, and the trial and subsequent execution were unique during the Civil War. While many parts of the movie are memorable, the most poignant scene is at the end when one of the major characters is buried in the cemetery. The camera zooms in on the white-painted headboard with his name, and then pans back to show you the real, present-day cemetery - with this particular headstone name in the center. Seeing nearly 13,000 headstones of real-life prisoners who died at Andersonville really puts the film in perspective.
yenlo
Generally these TNT original productions are nothing what one could call spectacular. This film from John Frankenheimer however is one of the better ones. A tale of imprisonment and survival inside the notorious Confederate POW camp known as Andersonville. Civil War historians would probably with certainty find various historical inaccuracies but it is worth viewing although a tad on the long side. Good performances from many of the cast but it seems Frederick Coffin and William Sanderson do the best job as two of the ring leaders of the camps vicious "Raiders" gang. A must see for any Civil War fan.
